The tub vs. shower debate is one of the most common questions in Boston bathroom renovations. The right answer depends on your household, how the bathroom is used daily, and whether you're optimizing for your own enjoyment or for resale value.
In Boston's real estate market, conventional wisdom says every home should have at least one bathtub. This is broadly accurate — buyers with young children consider a tub non-negotiable, and removing the only tub in a home can be a liability at resale. The nuance: in a multi-bathroom home where one bathroom retains a tub, converting the master bath to a walk-in shower is generally not a resale problem. In a one-bathroom condo or apartment, removing the only tub is a risk that may limit your buyer pool. NAR Remodeling Impact Report →
Nationally, tub usage drops significantly once households don't include young children. Most adults use the shower daily and the bathtub occasionally or never. In Boston's condo and apartment market — where many residents are young professionals or empty nesters — walk-in showers get significantly more use than tubs. A well-designed walk-in shower with a rainfall head, bench, and niche transforms daily routine in a way that a tub sitting unused doesn't. The question isn't just what increases resale value in theory; it's what you'll actually use for the years you're living there. NKBA bathroom design trends →
Converting a tub/shower combination to a walk-in shower requires new drain location, new waterproofing membrane, new tile or prefabricated shower unit, glass enclosure or open shower design, and plumbing rough-in adjustment. Cost in Boston runs $6,000–$15,000 depending on tile choice and glass enclosure style. This is real renovation work, not a simple swap. The investment is worthwhile if you'll use the shower daily for 10+ years. EPA WaterSense shower efficiency →
If a bathtub stays in the renovation, upgrading to a freestanding soaking tub creates a genuine luxury feature that photographs well for resale and adds daily use value. Freestanding tubs in Boston bathrooms require adequate floor space (60"x32" minimum footprint for most models), structural consideration if the floor needs to support 700+ pounds of water and occupant, and a floor-mounted or wall-mounted filler faucet. In Boston's older buildings, the floor structure and water supply locations need assessment before a freestanding tub can be specified. Call (617) 777-7700 for a free assessment. HomeAdvisor bathtub cost data →
Need Bathtub Installation in Boston?
AURA Painting Inc serves all Boston neighborhoods. Licensed MA #193121, fully insured, 2-year warranty. Free estimates — most jobs scheduled within the week.
Call (617) 777-7700 ← Back to Bathtub Installation